On October 27, 2026, the Federal government introduced Bill C-41, An Act to Amend the Criminal Code and An Act to Amend the Criminal Code (medical assistance in dying) and to make related amendments to other Acts (“Bill C-41). Bill C-41 would change Canada’s medical assistance in dying (“MAID”) framework in two significant ways:
- Indefinitely exclude MAID for mental illness, when it is the sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness from accessing MAID; and
- Allow advance requests for MAID if an individua later loses the capacity to consent.
Key Elements of Bill C-41
1. Exclude Mental Illness as the Sole Underlying Medical Condition
Bill C-41 would prohibit those whose sole underlying condition is mental illness from accessing MAID. This prohibition reflects the concerns raised by the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying in their report “Medical Assistance in Dying and Mental Disorder as the Sole Underlying Medical Condition: A Complex and Challenging Conversation Among Canadians” (“Report”).
As we have previously covered, the sole recommendation of the Report was to indefinitely exclude persons whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness from eligibility for MAID.
2. Allow Advance Requests for MAID
Bill C-41 would also allow for advance requests of MAID. This means that MAID could be provided to those who do not have the required capacity to consent to MAID when it is administered. In the Government of Canada’s news release, Alzheimers is named as an example illness that may allow for adults to “specify, in advance, the circumstances in which they would want MAID later in their illness .” The Government of Canada has also published a backgrounder on Bill C-41 to provide context and a plain language review.
The current law requires that “immediately before providing” MAID, the person “gives express consent to receive” it (241.2(3)(h); 241.2(3.1)(k)). This “final consent” can only be waived if a patient’s death is reasonably foreseeable, has met all eligibility criteria, entered into a written agreement with the doctor or nurse who would euthanize the patient on a specific day, has been informed of risk of losing capacity to consent, and in the written agreement has consented to MAID administration (241.2(3.2)(a)-(d)).
Bill C-41 expands MAID to those who are unable to provide meaningful consent. It would allow individuals to request MAID at a point in the future where they may not have consent as long as the requirements set out in the Criminal Code, RSC 1985, c C-46 (“Criminal Code”) are fulfilled. To be eligible for MAID on the basis of an advance request, the person must:
- Be eligible for publicly funded health services in Canada ;
- Have lost, due to the serious or incurable illness relating to the advance request, the capacity to consent to MAID;
- On an ongoing basis, present clinical symptoms described in their advance request;
- Be in a state of advanced and irreversible decline in capacity; and
- Experience “enduring and intolerable physical or psychological suffering that cannot be relieved through reasonable means”.
Bill C-41 outlines the safeguards it proposes , including:
- documentation of the request;
- independence of the medical or nurse practitioner providing MAID;
- if a person displays “by words, sounds or gestures, refusal or resistance to have [MAID] administered to them”, the practitioner administering MAID can no longer provide it to the individual in accordance with their advance request;
- if the medical practitioner has doubt regarding the person’s actions or gestures and whether they constitute refusal or resistance to MAID, practitioners must wait 30 days before administering MAID.
When making an advance request for MAID, individuals must:
- Make the decision voluntarily without external pressure;
- Be eligible for publicly funded health services in Canada;
- Be at least 18 years old and have capacity to make medical decisions;
- Be diagnosed with a serious or incurable illness or diseases that will reasonably lead to an irreversible loss in capacity to consent to MAID;
- Prepare the request with a nurse or medical practitioner, and if they practitioner did not have the required expertise on the illness the person was diagnosed with, the person consulted a practitioner who did have that expertise;
- Be informed of the nature of their diagnoses, the anticipated trajectory of the illness or disease, prognosis, options available to relieve their suffering, and that the means available to relieve their suffering may be different than when the request was made;
- Present clinical symptoms of the related disease or illness that they are requesting MAID for that are anticipated to cause “enduring and intolerable suffering” and for which they want to receive MAID for;
- Give the advanced request for MAID in the event they lose capacity and they exhibit clinical manifestations described in the request;
- Be informed of how to withdraw, amend or replace the request in accordance with the provincial regime in place before they sign the advance request; and
- Be advised of all the legislative requirements to request MAID.
Advance requests for MAID relating to a mental illness are prohibited under Bill C-41. Bill C-41 only allows advance requests for MAID in provinces that have legislation in place that satisfies applicable record-keeping requirements.
Current Status of Bill C-41
Bill C-41 is currently at second reading in the House of Commons and has been referred to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights for further review. While there have been concerns raised by Parliament about Bill C-41, Members of Parliament have voted to both limit the debates and to send Bill C-41 to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights. The purpose of studying bills by parliamentary committees is to examine them closely on a clause-by-clause basis, as well as consulting with experts and listening to the perspectives of Canadians on the bills being studied.
Provincial Responses to Bill C-21
Alberta
Earlier in 2026, Alberta passed legislation to prohibit MAID for mental illness or by advance request, as well as requiring natural death to be reasonably foreseeable within 12 months. While this legislation is not yet in force, Alberta’s additional safeguards relating to MAID limit its rapid expansion and support the establishment of MAID-free healthcare facilities.
Saskatchewan
Recently, Saskatchewan introduced Bill-73, An Act respecting Additional Safeguards in Medical Assistance in Dying (“Bill-73”). Bill-73 prohibits medical practitioners from administering MAID when:
- The individual is less than 18 years of age;
- The individual lacks capacity to make decisions about MAID, specifically information relating to their decision, appreciating reasonably foreseeable consequences of making a decision relating to MAID, and communicating a decision about MAID; and
- The sole underlying condition for the request for MAID relates to mental illness.
In their news release, the government of Saskatchewan Health Minister detailed the purpose of Bill-73 as a means to have “additional safeguards, particularly around young people, mental illness, and capacity, and strengthens protections for health care professionals who choose to not participate in MAID.”
Quebec
Despite current Criminal Code prohibitions on advanced directives for MAID, Quebec currently allows for advance requests for MAID. Since a legal challenge in the Superior Court of Quebec to the MAID regime in 2019, Quebec has held that it is unconstitutional to prohibit advance requests for MAID. While only available in french, Quebec’s Director of Criminal and Penal Prosecutions issued a directive to not initiate criminal proceedings against medical practitioners who administer MAID where death is not reasonably foreseeable.
We’re Here to Help
We will continue to post updates about Bill C-41 on our Blog. If you are a CCCC Member with questions or need support, please contact our Member Support Team by phone or email. Our Member Support Team is here to help you.
The content provided in this blog is for general information purposes and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Every organization’s circumstances are unique. Before acting on the basis of information contained in this blog, readers should consult with a qualified lawyer for advice specific to their situation.